Sunday, November 9, 2025

Sizzling Buttered Rum – A Lovely Mess

Relating to wintertime drinks, cozying up by the fireplace with a scorching buttered rum is the highest strategy to cross the time on a chilly winter’s evening. Whereas the identify could sound odd, this scorching buttered rum recipe is definitely a scrumptious drink that mixes candy, creamy, and buttery flavors with winter spices and a dose of rum to heat you from the within out.

You may simply make a batch of scorching buttered rum “batter” to maintain in your fridge so you can also make this Christmas cocktail at a second’s discover, and you’ll even make it with out the alcohol to be a family-friendly drink. Take a look at our tutorial video to see how straightforward it’s to make!

Associated: Wassail Recipe, Glühwein (German Mulled Wine), Mulled Wine, Do-it-yourself Sizzling Chocolate, Do-it-yourself Eggnog, Traditional Sizzling Toddy, Apple Cinnamon Sizzling Toddy, Cranberry Spiced Sizzling Toddy

hot buttered rumhot buttered rum

What’s the historical past of scorching buttered rum?

Sizzling buttered rum dates all the way in which again to the American colonial interval of New England within the 1650s. Rum was a well-liked drink as water wasn’t at all times protected to drink and the new buttered rum was an alternative choice to a scorching toddy because it additionally added some energy. The essential recipe consisted of rum, butter, spices, and sugar, that are nonetheless the principle elements in trendy scorching buttered rums.

What does scorching buttered rum style like?

Whereas the identify could not sound appetizing to some, scorching buttered rum has a creamy candy style punctuated with heat spices like cinnamon and nutmeg. The butter does give the drink a scrumptious buttery taste much like consuming a buttery cookie in a glass!

What sort of rum is greatest for warm buttered rum?

Whereas it’s attainable to make use of white rum if that’s all you could have available (and if that’s the rum you favor), spiced rum or darkish rum is a greater taste profile for this specific drink. Spiced rum may have some added caramel taste and spices whereas darkish rum will probably be a bit of extra of a darker molasses taste profile.

hot buttered rum ingredientshot buttered rum ingredients

Sizzling buttered rum elements:

Unsalted butter: That is the buttery a part of your scorching buttered rum!

Brown sugar: You’ll get candy notes of caramel by including brown sugar to your batter combine.

Powdered sugar: Including some powdered sugar offers the drink a lighter sweetness on prime of the deeper brown sugar taste.

Floor cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove: These heat spices mixed collectively make this drink style like Christmas in a glass! Be happy so as to add some floor allspice or cardamom as properly for much more ranges of spice.

Vanilla extract: Attempt to use vanilla extract quite than imitation vanilla for a extra pure vanilla taste.

Rum: A darkish or spiced rum is your best option for the right scorching buttered rum.

Sizzling water: Including scorching water to your scorching buttered rum batter is what offers you a heat and comfy drink.

TIP: Moderately than boiling water, you’ll wish to use scorching water that’s just below boiling as water that’s too scorching can uninteresting the flavors a bit of.

Easy methods to make scorching buttered rum

For the batter:

Add unsalted butter to a small saucepan over medium-low warmth. Stir till butter is melted after which whisk in your brown and powdered sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg and clove till sugar is melted and elements are mixed.

Take away from warmth and add in your vanilla and stir to mix. Use to make scorching buttered rum or permit to chill after which retailer within the fridge in an hermetic container till prepared to make use of.

For the new buttered rum:

Add 2 tablespoons of the butter combination to a heatproof mug and pour in 6 ounces scorching water and 1-2 ounces of rum relying on how robust you need your drink. Stir and add extra batter to style if crucial and luxuriate in!

TIP: Since you might be including scorching water to your drink, you don’t need to warmth the rum as properly, so be at liberty to make use of room temperature rum.

hot buttered rumhot buttered rum

Suggestions for making scorching buttered rum:

  • Add a splash of salt to your batter to actually carry out the flavors.
  • Including a dollop of whipped cream to the highest of your drink is not going to solely look fairly, however it can add additional creamy sweetness because it melts into the drink.
  • Sprinkle some cinnamon or freshly grated nutmeg on prime of your drink or add in a cinnamon stick earlier than serving for a lift of cinnamon taste.

TIP: To maintain your drink heat longer, serve the new buttered rum in pre-warmed mugs!

How do you make scorching buttered rum nonalcoholic?

To make a family-friendly model of scorching buttered rum, merely use simply the batter and scorching water to make your scrumptious drink. You can too add the batter into milk, apple cider, or espresso for a nonalcoholic deal with.

How do you make scorching buttered rum in a crockpot?

To make scorching buttered rum for a crowd in a sluggish cooker, put the batter elements into the crockpot first and prepare dinner on excessive till all of the elements are blended collectively (about 30-60 minutes).

Add in your scorching water and rum and cut back warmth to low till able to serve. Ladle into mugs and garnish as desired earlier than serving.

How lengthy does scorching buttered rum batter final within the fridge?

Sizzling buttered rum batter will final within the fridge in an hermetic container for 1-2 weeks.

You can too put it within the freezer and it’ll final round 3 months frozen. Simply let thaw within the fridge earlier than utilizing.

Can you employ salted butter in scorching buttered rum?

Whereas most recipes name for unsalted butter so you possibly can management the salt degree to style, you may also use salted butter with nice outcomes.

hot buttered rumhot buttered rum

Sizzling buttered rum variations:

Make it with tea: Use your favourite black tea luggage to brew tea along with your scorching water earlier than including it to your drink.

Play with spices: Attempt including ginger, allspice, or cardamom to your batter till your attain your favourite spice combo.

Swap the rum: You may attempt brandy, whiskey, or cognac rather than the rum for a twist on the traditional.

Make it with ice cream: It’s additionally standard so as to add some melted vanilla ice cream to your scorching buttered rum batter for additional creamy sweetness.

Add notes of orange: Orange is such a well-liked vacation taste as properly so attempt some orange zest within the batter or a contact of orange extract.

Attempt these festive appetizers at your vacation celebration!


Print

get the recipeget the recipe
Get the Recipe

This scorching buttered rum recipe is nice, creamy, and buttery with heat winter spices and a dose of rum.

Yield 5 drinks

Prep 10 minutes

Whole 10 minutes

Sizzling Buttered Rum Cocktail

Directions

For the batter:

  • Add unsalted butter to a small saucepan over medium-low warmth. Stir till butter is melted after which whisk in your brown and powdered sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg and clove till sugar is melted and elements are mixed.

  • Take away from warmth and add in your vanilla and stir to mix.

  • Use to make scorching buttered rum or permit to chill after which retailer within the fridge in an hermetic container till prepared to make use of.

For the cocktail:

  • Add 2 tablespoons of the batter combination to a heatproof mug and pour in 6-8 ounces scorching water and 1-2 ounces of rum relying on how robust you need your drink.

  • Stir and add extra batter to style if crucial and luxuriate in!

Notes

Retailer within the fridge in an hermetic container.

Suggestions for making scorching buttered rum:

  • Add a splash of salt to your batter to actually carry out the flavors.
  • Including a dollop of whipped cream to the highest of your drink is not going to solely look fairly, however it can add additional creamy sweetness because it melts into the drink.
  • Sprinkle some cinnamon or freshly grated nutmeg on prime of your drink or add in a cinnamon stick earlier than serving for a lift of cinnamon taste.

 
TIP: Moderately than boiling water, you’ll wish to use scorching water that’s just below boiling as water that’s too scorching can uninteresting the flavors a bit of.
TIP: To maintain your drink heat longer, serve the new buttered rum in pre-warmed mugs!

Vitamin

Vitamin Information

Sizzling Buttered Rum

Quantity per Serving

% Day by day Worth*

* % Day by day Values are primarily based on a 2000 calorie weight-reduction plan.

Discover: Vitamin is auto-calculated, utilizing Spoonacular, to your comfort. The place related, we advocate utilizing your personal vitamin calculations.

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles